Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition
Combined Science · Lessons

Select a graph type for a mixed investigation

You have a table of results and a blank grid, and the graph you pick decides how much of the pattern shows.

On this page
  1. What decides the graph type?
  2. Step by step
  3. Worked example
  4. The mistake to watch for
  5. Check yourself
  6. Where this leads next

Choose the graph from the type of each variable. If the variable you changed is a category, draw a bar chart. If both variables are measured numbers, draw a line graph or scatter graph with a best-fit line.

This is a core skill in cross-science data interpretation, because one exam paper can mix biology, chemistry and physics tables. All data here is invented for practice.

What decides the graph type?

Ask two questions. First, is the independent variable a category (names, types, groups) or a number (time, concentration, mass)? Second, if it is a number, can it take any value in a range, or only separate values?

Independent variableDependent variableDisplay
CategoryNumberBar chart, gaps between bars
Number, any value in a rangeNumberLine graph or scatter graph with line of best fit
Number, grouped into classesFrequencyHistogram or bar chart (check the question wording)

Step by step

  1. Name the independent and dependent variables. Write the units.
  2. Check the type of the independent variable using the table.
  3. Choose axis scales so the plotted points fill more than half of the grid in both directions. Use even steps such as 2, 4, 6.
  4. Plot carefully with small crosses or dots, then draw the line or bars.
  5. Add a title or clear axis labels that include units.

Worked example

A student studies how the temperature of hot water changes while it cools in an open beaker. Invented data:

Time (min)0246810
Temperature (°C)806859524743

Step 1: the independent variable is time (min), the dependent variable is temperature (°C).

Step 2: both are numbers that vary continuously, so a line graph suits. Time goes on the x-axis.

Step 3: x runs 0 to 10 min in steps of 2. The y-axis can run from 40 °C to 80 °C in steps of 10, so the points fill the grid instead of crowding in one corner.

Step 4: plot the six points and draw a smooth curve. It falls steeply at first (12 °C in the first 2 min) and flattens (4 °C in the last 2 min). A straight line of best fit would hide that shape.

The reading from the graph: the fall is faster when the water is hotter. That is an interpretation, not just a description.

A different task compares the mass of three metal samples by type. Type of metal is a category, so that needs a bar chart.

The mistake to watch for

Mistaken answer: a line graph joining “copper, iron, zinc” with a sloping line.

A line between categories implies there are values in between, which makes no sense for metals. The correction is to draw separate bars with gaps.

A second slip is starting the y-axis at 0 when all values lie between 40 and 80. That squashes the pattern into one corner of the grid.

Check yourself

1. Which graph suits “number of seeds that germinate in four soil types”?

Show answer

Soil type is a category, so a bar chart with gaps between the bars.

2. Which graph suits “current through a resistor as the voltage changes from 0 to 6 V”?

Show answer

Both variables are numbers, so plot a scatter graph with a line of best fit. Voltage goes on the x-axis.

3. Your temperatures run from 61 °C to 79 °C. Why is a y-axis from 0 to 100 a poor choice?

Show answer

The points would fill less than half the grid vertically and the pattern would look flat. Use something like 60 to 80 °C.

Where this leads next

Return to comparing datasets in different units if the data itself is the problem, or move on to explaining an anomaly without deleting it. The scientific investigation critic prompts you to justify your choice.

When a student’s graph is correct but the reasoning behind it is vague, one-to-one attention helps. Our online Combined Science tuition can work on that with your own tables.

Questions people ask

When do I use a bar chart instead of a line graph?

Use a bar chart when the independent variable is a category, such as type of fertiliser or metal. Use a line or scatter graph when both variables are numbers that can take any value in a range, such as time and temperature.

Should I join the points with straight lines?

Only when the question suggests a connect-the-dots record, such as a cooling curve with few readings. For most investigations, draw a smooth line or straight line of best fit that follows the trend and passes close to most points.

Which variable goes on the x-axis?

The independent variable, the one you change, goes on the x-axis. The dependent variable, the one you measure, goes on the y-axis. Label both axes with the quantity and the unit.

Updated:

Your next step

If graph choices still feel like a coin toss, a one-to-one teacher can review your own practical tables and explain why one display shows the pattern and another hides it.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80. Other fees, schedules and ongoing arrangements are confirmed directly with your teacher after the trial class.

Tuition is arranged with a parent or guardian. Send them this page on WhatsApp and they can enquire for you.

Parent or guardian? Enquire here

9,000+ students helped through our service