要口头比较不同选项,先说出两个选项,各给一个要点,再说你偏向哪一个以及原因。这样的短框架让你能用自己的想法组织回答,而不是背一篇可能不适合问题的讲稿。
为什么背好的独白会失败?
背好的讲稿回答的是你准备的问题,而不是被问到的问题。背诵时声音也会变得平板,对方听得出来,下一个问题就会打断它。
框架不同。它只是几个路标,里面填的是新鲜的想法,所以无论被问到哪两件事都适用。
可以用什么框架?
- 说出两个选项。 “You are asking about studying at home and studying in a library.”
- 给第一个选项一个要点。 “At home, it is comfortable and I can take breaks when I need them.”
- 给第二个选项一个要点。 “In a library, it is quiet, so I am less tempted to check my phone.”
- 说出你的偏好和理由。 “For me, the library is better, because my main problem is distraction.”
四句话就够了。如果对方追问,可以再补一个简短的例子。
例题详解
问题:“Would you rather spend a holiday at the beach or in a city?”
第一步,说出选项: “That is a difficult choice, because both are attractive.”
第二步,海滩的要点: “At the beach, I can relax and forget about deadlines.”
第三步,城市的要点: “In a city, there is more to do, for example museums, food and shopping.”
第四步,偏好与理由: “I would choose the city, because I get bored if I lie still for too long.”
完整回答: “That is a difficult choice, because both are attractive. At the beach, I can relax and forget about deadlines, whereas in a city there is more to do, for example museums, food and shopping. I would choose the city, because I get bored if I lie still for too long.”
这里不需要背稿。只有框架是记住的,想法都是当场生成的。
要留意的错误
常见的失误是一听到话题词,就把知道的内容全背出来。
错误回答: “Holidays are important for health. Many people travel every year. Tourism helps the economy…”
学生听到 “holiday” 就开始背准备好的讲稿。对方想要的是在海滩和城市之间做选择,却一直没得到。
改正的方法是使用问题里的原话:那两个选项。在回答开头说出它们,并以做出选择作结。如果脑中一片空白,先说 “let me think”,再用框架的第一步。
自我检测
先大声用四句话回答,再打开参考答案。
1. “Is it better to have one close friend or many friends?”
查看答案
一种可能的回答:“Both have value. With one close friend, you can talk about anything and trust them, whereas with many friends there is always someone to do activities with. I think one close friend matters more to me, because I can be honest about problems.” 这个例子说出了两者,各给一个要点,并做出选择。
2. “Would you prefer to read a book or watch the film of the same story?”
查看答案
一种可能的回答:“A book lets me imagine the characters my own way, but a film is faster and has music. I would choose the film when I am tired, but the book when I want to think. Overall, I prefer books, because the details stay in my mind longer.” 说 “it depends” 也可以,只要随后加以解释。
3. 哪三个短语可以用来开始一个比较回答?
查看答案
任何自然的组合都可以,例如 “On the one hand…”、“Compared with…”、“The advantage of… is…”。选你说起来舒服的,而不是一长串清单。
下一步
下一项技能是应对没想到的问题:回应意料之外的追问。然后试试口语互动练习题组。
如果你只在排练过的话题上听起来流利,老师可以丢给你新的选择题,帮你在English as a Second Language 线上一对一补习中建立自己的框架。