Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition
Economics · Lessons

Compare effects on hypothetical households without political ranking

Evaluation questions ask who gains and who loses, and the strongest answers describe effects without declaring which outcome is worse.

On this page
  1. What is the method?
  2. Worked example
  3. The mistake to watch for
  4. Check yourself
  5. Where this leads next

To compare effects fairly, take a hypothetical household, state what happens to its income, its savings or its debts, and calculate the change in purchasing power. Then describe the result as a conditional statement. This lesson uses fictional households so that no real group or policy is judged.

It builds on the price level and rate lesson and the unemployment mechanisms in inflation and unemployment.

What is the method?

  1. Name the household and its situation.
  2. Choose the measure: real income, real value of savings, or real burden of debt.
  3. Adjust for price change: real value = money value ÷ (1 + inflation rate), in terms of last year’s prices.
  4. State the effect with a condition, such as “if wages stay fixed”.
  5. Avoid ranking. Say who is affected and by how much.

Worked example

Suppose inflation in Lestari is 5% for the year. Four fictional households are described.

HouseholdSituationMoney changeReal value after 5% inflation
AiniSalary RM3,000, unchangednone3,000 ÷ 1.05 = RM2,857 (about 4.8% lower)
BudiSalary RM3,000 rises 5% to RM3,150+RM1503,150 ÷ 1.05 = RM3,000 (unchanged)
ChenHolds RM10,000 cashnone10,000 ÷ 1.05 = RM9,524
DeviOwes RM10,000, fixed amountnone10,000 ÷ 1.05 = RM9,524 burden

Step 1, Aini: salary buys about RM143 less in last year’s prices, because 3,000 − 2,857 = 143.

Step 2, Budi: his wage matched inflation, so his purchasing power is unchanged.

Step 3, Chen and Devi: the same RM9,524 appears twice. Chen’s cash buys less, which is a loss in purchasing power of about RM476. Devi’s repayment is worth less in real terms, so her burden falls by the same amount.

Step 4, add the condition. If the interest on Devi’s loan rises with inflation, her real burden would not fall. If the interest Chen earns on his cash rises, his loss shrinks.

Step 5, an unemployment household. Eka loses a job paying RM3,000 a month and uses savings. Her income falls to zero during the search, and the result depends on how long the search takes and how large her savings are. No price calculation is needed, but the same conditional style applies.

The mistake to watch for

Mistaken answer: “Inflation is bad because it hurts everyone.”

The student ignored Devi, whose fixed debt burden falls in real terms, and Budi, whose purchasing power is unchanged.

The correction is to describe each household separately and use conditions: “Inflation reduces the real value of fixed salaries and cash savings, while fixed debts fall in real terms, unless wages or interest rates adjust.”

Check yourself

1. Prices rise 5% and a worker’s wage rises 3%. What is the approximate real change in income?

Show answer

1.03 ÷ 1.05 = 0.981, so real income falls about 1.9%.

2. A household owes a fixed RM20,000 and inflation is 4%. Find the real value of the debt in last year’s prices.

Show answer

20,000 ÷ 1.04 = RM19,231 (to the nearest ringgit). The real burden has fallen by about RM769.

3. Rewrite “unemployment is worse than inflation” as an analytical statement.

Show answer

One example: “A household that loses its only income faces a larger fall in spending than one whose wage lags 2% behind prices, though the effect depends on savings, the length of the job search and other support.” The statement names a measure and a condition rather than ranking.

Where this leads next

Finish the module with separating correlation from a claimed cause, then try the mixed practice set. The percentage-base explorer helps check the real-value calculations.

Evaluation is where a teacher’s questions help most, because the gap is usually wording and not knowledge. That is a natural fit for online one-to-one Economics tuition.

Questions people ask

Does inflation always hurt savers and help borrowers?

Not always. A fixed sum of money buys less after prices rise, which favours a borrower repaying a fixed amount and disadvantages a saver holding cash. But if interest rates or wages adjust, the effect changes. Say 'if' and name the condition.

How do I evaluate without giving my opinion?

Describe who is affected, by how much and under which assumptions, then state what the evidence supports. Avoid words such as 'worse' or 'unfair' unless you define the measure. Conditional wording and calculated differences keep the answer analytical.

What is a real change?

A real change adjusts a money amount for price changes so you can see purchasing power. If income rises 3% while prices rise 5%, income has gone up in money terms but down in real terms, because it buys less than before.

Updated:

Your next step

If your evaluation paragraphs drift into opinions, a one-to-one teacher can help you turn each claim into a conditional statement backed by numbers.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80. Other fees, schedules and ongoing arrangements are confirmed directly with your teacher after the trial class.

Tuition is arranged with a parent or guardian. Send them this page on WhatsApp and they can enquire for you.

Parent or guardian? Enquire here

9,000+ students helped through our service