Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition
Mathematics · Lessons

Check a solution in the original relationship

An answer can look tidy and still be wrong, and the working you just wrote is the last place to find out.

On this page
  1. What is the idea behind it?
  2. How to do it, step by step
  3. Worked example
  4. The mistake to watch for
  5. Check yourself
  6. Where this leads next

To check a solution, substitute your answer into the original equation, evaluate the left side and the right side separately, and confirm they are equal. This habit turns a doubtful answer into a verified one and gives you confidence in any algebra question.

It closes the route through equations and formulas and pairs with every lesson before it.

What is the idea behind it?

A solution is a value that makes the original relationship true. So the only test that matters is whether the original relationship is true when that value is put in.

Checking is not repeating the solution. It is a different calculation that approaches the answer from the other direction, which is why it catches mistakes that redoing the same steps would miss.

How to do it, step by step

  1. Copy the original equation (not a later line).
  2. Substitute your value for every occurrence of the letter, using brackets round negatives.
  3. Evaluate the left side completely on its own.
  4. Evaluate the right side completely on its own.
  5. Compare. Equal means correct. Different means go back.
  6. For a word problem, also ask whether the answer fits the story.

Worked example

Solve 7 − 2(x − 1) = x + 12 and verify.

Step 1, expand: 7 − 2x + 2 = x + 12, so 9 − 2x = x + 12.

Step 2, collect: subtract x and 12: −3 = 3x, so x = −1.

Check in the original: left side 7 − 2(−1 − 1) = 7 − 2 × (−2) = 7 + 4 = 11. Right side −1 + 12 = 11. Both equal 11. ✓

The mistake to watch for

The trap is checking in a line you already rearranged.

Mistaken working: 7 − 2(x − 1) becomes 7 − 2x − 2 (the sign of the second term is wrong). Then 5 − 2x = x + 12, so −7 = 3x and x = −7/3.

Checking in 5 − 2x = x + 12 passes: 5 + 14/3 = 29/3 and −7/3 + 12 = 29/3.

That check agrees because the error is built into the line being tested. In the original: left side 7 − 2(−7/3 − 1) = 7 + 20/3 = 41/3, while the right side is 29/3. They differ, so the answer is wrong.

The correction is to always scroll back up to the original question and copy that line, nothing else.

Check yourself

1. A student solves 4(x + 3) = 2x + 20 and gets x = 2. Is this right? If not, find the correct value.

Show answer

Check x = 2 in the original: left side 4 × 5 = 20, right side 2 × 2 + 20 = 24. These differ, so it is wrong.

Solve: 4x + 12 = 2x + 20, so 2x = 8 and x = 4. Check: 4 × 7 = 28 and 8 + 20 = 28. ✓ The correct value is x = 4.

2. Solve 3(x + 5) = 2 − x and check your answer.

Show answer

Expand: 3x + 15 = 2 − x. Add x: 4x + 15 = 2. Subtract 15: 4x = −13. So x = −13/4.

Check: left side 3(−13/4 + 5) = 3 × 7/4 = 21/4. Right side 2 + 13/4 = 21/4. ✓

3. A student rearranges P = 2(l + w) and writes w = P − 2l. Test the formula with l = 5 and w = 3. Is it correct?

Show answer

With l = 5 and w = 3, P = 2 × 8 = 16. The student’s formula gives w = 16 − 10 = 6, which is not 3. So it is wrong.

The correct rearrangement is w = P/2 − l. Test: 16/2 − 5 = 3. ✓

Where this leads next

Put all five lessons together in the equations and formulas practice set, and record any slips in the mistake log and retest queue. When you meet two unknowns, simultaneous relationships uses the same checking habit on two equations at once.

If you want someone to read your checking line by line, that is what online one-to-one Mathematics tuition can offer.

Questions people ask

Why must I check in the original equation and not my last line?

If you made an error earlier, your later lines are built on it and will agree with each other. A check in the last line can then pass even though the answer is wrong. The original question has no errors in it, so it is the fair test.

How long should a check take?

Usually under a minute. Substitute into each side, calculate separately, and compare the two values. Do not try to rearrange anything during a check, because that brings the risk of new mistakes.

Does the check prove the answer for a word problem?

It proves the equation is solved. You must also test the answer against the wording, for example that a length is positive and a count of tickets is a whole number. Both checks together confirm the answer makes sense.

Updated:

Your next step

If you rarely catch your own errors before handing work in, a one-to-one teacher can build a short checking routine with you and practise it on your real questions.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80. Other fees, schedules and ongoing arrangements are confirmed directly with your teacher after the trial class.

Tuition is arranged with a parent or guardian. Send them this page on WhatsApp and they can enquire for you.

Parent or guardian? Enquire here

9,000+ students helped through our service