Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition

Study routes

Check a solution using a second method

You finish a question, feel unsure, and have no way to know if the answer is right without the mark scheme.

On this page
  1. Which second methods work?
  2. Worked example
  3. The mistake to watch for
  4. How do I build this into my routine?
  5. Self-check
  6. When might one-to-one tuition be worth considering?

The simplest way to check a solution is to test the answer against the original question using a different route: substitute it back, estimate it, or reverse the calculation. If both routes agree, you can be far more confident.

This habit helps most where you understand the method but lose marks through slips. The original mixed-practice builder gives you varied questions to practise it on.

Which second methods work?

Type of questionA second method
EquationsSubstitute the answer into the original equation
Percentage changeReverse the change and see if you return to the start
Speed, distance, timeUse a different form of the formula
Quadratic rootsSubstitute each root back
Any numerical answerRound the numbers and estimate roughly

Worked example

Question: A jacket costs RM340 after a 15% discount. What was the original price?

First method: After a 15% discount the price is 85% of the original. So original = 340 ÷ 0.85 = RM400.

Second method, reverse it: 15% of 400 = 60, and 400 − 60 = 340. This matches the question, so RM400 is correct.

Estimation as a quick third check: 85% is a little under 90%, and 90% of 400 is 360, so 85% of 400 is a little under 360. The exact value, 340, fits that picture.

The mistake to watch for

A common slip is to think “15% off, so add 15% back” and calculate 340 × 1.15 = 391.

Test it with the reverse method. 15% of 391 = 58.65, and 391 − 58.65 = 332.35. This is not 340, so 391 cannot be the original price.

The discount applies to the original price, which is why dividing by 0.85 is correct.

The check does not only tell you that you were wrong. It shows you why.

How do I build this into my routine?

  1. After each question, ask “what is one quick way to test this?”
  2. Write the check on the same page, in one or two lines.
  3. If the check fails, find the step where the two routes split.
  4. Keep a short list of the checks you used for each topic.

Self-check

  1. A student says the roots of x² − 5x + 6 = 0 are 2 and 3. Check them.
Show answer x = 2: 4 − 10 + 6 = 0. x = 3: 9 − 15 + 6 = 0. Both work, so the roots are correct.
  1. A car travels 150 km in 2 hours 30 minutes. A student says the average speed is 60 km/h. Check it.
Show answer Reverse it: 60 × 2.5 = 150 km. This matches, so 60 km/h is correct.
  1. A price increases by 20% to RM90. A student says the original was RM70. Check it.
Show answer Increase 70 by 20%: 70 × 1.2 = 84, not 90. So RM70 is wrong. The correct original is 90 ÷ 1.2 = RM75, and 75 × 1.2 = 90.

When might one-to-one tuition be worth considering?

Self-study may be enough when checking catches most of your slips. Tuition may be worth considering when you do check but cannot find the error, or when answers differ and you do not know which method to trust.

A teacher can watch you check a real question and show a faster route. See building an independent route, deciding whether targeted tuition adds value, and the Mathematics tuition page.

Questions people ask

Does checking take too long in an exam?

A quick check usually takes less time than redoing a whole question. Substitution and estimation can take seconds. Practise them at home so they feel automatic, and use them first on questions worth more marks.

Should the second method be different, or the same one again?

Use a different route where you can. Repeating the same steps tends to repeat the same slip. Substituting back, estimating, or working backwards catches different errors.

What if the two methods disagree?

That is useful. One of them has an error. Look at each step of the shorter method first, then the longer one. Do not choose the answer you prefer.

Can I use this for every topic?

Most topics have a check. Equations can be substituted back, percentages reversed, geometry checked against a sketch, and graphs tested at a point. Learn one or two checks per topic.

Sources

  1. Cambridge IGCSE Mathematics 0580 syllabus page

Updated:

Your next step

If you can follow a method but cannot tell when your answer is wrong, a one-to-one teacher can build a checking habit around the questions you actually get wrong.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80. Other fees, schedules and ongoing arrangements are confirmed directly with your teacher after the trial class.

9,000+ students helped through our service